So yea, we just paid a whole bunch of money for the plumber to take off our toilet, look underneath and find that the brand new toilet we just bought is damaged! We bought a lemon. Ugh. So, now we have to return it to Home Depot, purchase another one, and reset the thing again and hope it works. The good news: the plumber inspected everything around the toilet and said the flange and piping looked great. So, hopefully after this minor set back, we'll be rolling on to a brand new bathroom!!! Stay tuned for finished photos!